• Home
  • Guides
  • Resources
  • Blogroll
  • Contact
  • Authors
  • Tree Shirts
  • Entries | Comments
  • Subscribe via E-Mail
  • Tree Shirts
  • Recent Comments
  • Mana Regen Calc.
  • The World Tree

Favorites

  • /hug
  • 4 Haelz
  • Banana Shoulders
  • Big Bear Butt
  • BigRedKitty
  • Gray Matter
  • Leafshine: Lust for Flower
  • Lume the Mad
  • Of Teeth and Claws
  • Out of Mana
  • Parry! Dodge! Spin!
  • Think Tank
  • Tree Bark Jacket
  • Unbearably HoT
  • Yet Another Warlock Nerf
  • View Full Blogroll

Recent Achievements

Blogroll Highlights

  • Leafshine: Lust for Flower
  • Pookies is not a Bear
  • Mooonfire
  • Friendly Feral Druid
  • Moon Chicken

Categories

Archives

I blog Azeroth. Do you?

Creative Commons License

Featured Post

Featured: Spell Power, +Healing, and Coefficients

By now, you’ve almost certainly heard about the change to itemization whereby the +Healing and +Spell Damage stats are being retired for the less specialized Spell Power stat. What, exactly does this mean, though, and what can you expect at the release of Patch 3.0?

Read More | All Featured Posts

Recent Posts

  • Living Seed, Replenish, and Gift of the Earthmother
  • Guest Post: Leveraging Shadowmeld
  • 2008: A Retrospective
  • U.S. and Canada: Save 20.09% on Resto4Life Tree Shirts!

Currant A Plethora of Claws

Published on November 19, 2008 by Currant
Blue, Spells and Talents
24 Comments

So it appears that kitties will be getting an AoE ability:

Yeah, if I can offer a suggestion, please don’t disregard a player’s argument just because their class is good in aspects of the game you care about that the OP may not. :)

We think we are going to remove the cooldown of Fan of Knives altogether. There are just too many PvE situations where rogues feel at a disadvantage without a reliable ranged attack. The example that came up recently is Meathook in CoT:Stratholme and having the spawning zombies causing pushback on your healers. Rogues can FoK once and then have to run over to help the healer.

And in case it gets asked, Feral druids we haven’t forgotten about your AE either.

We’ll try and announce something soon.

I CAN HAZ ADAMANTIUM?Or is that really what that comment means?  Not forgetting about it doesn’t actually mean they’re going to give it to us, just that they’re thinking about it.

What do you think about that?  How would that work?  Would we Purr the enemy to death, rattling the integrity of their skeletal structure into nothing but a fine powder?  Maybe the Angry-Kitty Death Shriek where we make that creepy baby sound cats make when they’re hurt, tearing the tympanum from the eardrums of our foes with an awful wail?  Or could it be the Spastic LoLCat Scritch-Scratch, blinking from alien girl to alien girl like James T. Kirk on Red Bull?

Who knows?

Related Posts

  • Indoor Roots and Mark(ed) Improvements
  • Barkskin to be Usable in Cat and Travel Forms
  • Druids Have the Blues
Categories: Blue, Spells and Talents

24 Comments

Make A Comment | Set My Avatar
  • Gravatar Veneretio

    I’m confused. Don’t you already have Swipe as an AOE ability for Feral Druids?

    Veneretios last blog post..Killing Kritters 2.0 - WotLK Edition

    6:50 pm on 11/19/08
  • Gravatar Thalium

    The kitty would shake their booty, spreading vile ticks and fleas all over the enemies! The feral insect swarm!

    6:51 pm on 11/19/08
  • Gravatar Phil

    I’m like meh on the subject. I think rogues are just sad that they aren’t the best at dps in AoE situations. Which makes sense to me. But I can see where the bring the player not the class aspect where a group of friends might not have the main AoE spec’s available. But giving rogues AoE seems to be a bit extreme.

    Phils last blog post..5 Tricks For Dominating Gears of War 2 Multiplayer

    7:02 pm on 11/19/08
  • Gravatar Currant

    Veneretios, while that is certainly a form of AoE damage, the problem comes with the increased threat of the form. Bare iz 4 tank.

    7:24 pm on 11/19/08
  • Gravatar Shasmo

    I think it would go something like this:

    Name: Bath Time
    Effect: You (as a kitty) instantly go into a killing frenzy, clawing at all enemies in 10 yards. Bath Time lasts for 10 seconds, and you cannot be interrupted. After the Bath Time effect ends, you will have a debuff called ‘Clean’ for 2 minutes and you will not be able to have another Bath for the duration.

    Because every kitty-cat I have had during my life has managed to perform an AoE attack on everyone present whenever we try to give it a bath!

    Shasmos last blog post..Facepalm Moments

    7:26 pm on 11/19/08
  • Gravatar Phaelia

    @Shasmo: ROFL … okay, that’s probably one of the best comments I’ve ever gotten!

    7:35 pm on 11/19/08
  • Gravatar archmera

    Oh my goodness, i have to agree with Phae on that one, having a kitten myself, i know exactly how that can be. Kudos to Shasmo LOL!

    1:30 am on 11/20/08
  • Gravatar Marc

    I consider the Tauren cat form an AoE ability. It’s that ugly!

    4:18 am on 11/20/08
  • Gravatar Warscreamer

    heh..
    despite I’m rather feral tank now, I would love to see some AoE on kitten.
    this could be nice to mark mobs during questing..
    stealth, aoe, bear form, swipe swipe swipe…

    I totally love FoK because of one trick.

    Stealth -> Tricks of the Trade (http://www.wowhead.com/?spell=57934) on me -> FoK…
    best pulling machine ever.
    all mobs on tank more time for sheeping or stuff.

    4:40 am on 11/20/08
  • Gravatar Lotha

    They could cough up a few hairballs, or something on the more disgusting side spray.

    7:08 am on 11/20/08
  • Gravatar Arghor

    I think this is ridiculous. Now every class needs to be the same? Everyone needs AoE? I´m a feral druid, and if I want to AoE, then i´ll shift to bear form. And we still have Hurricane too. Druids don´t need another AoE. I can´t imagine a cat doing an AoE damage. Cats are single target by nature. I really hope Blizzard doesn´t implement that.

    7:48 am on 11/20/08
  • Gravatar Karthis

    @Currant:

    I always use bear form on AOE pulls, and don’t have an aggro management issue if I wait a second or two before going nuts. And even if I did manage to pull aggro, I can take multiple hits in bear form just fine…. if it’s bothering me, that’s what cower is for.

    Swipe is just fine - cats don’t need a special AOE ability. (Nor do rogues, to be quite honest - they do great damage as is)

    Karthiss last blog post..The Other Half

    10:22 am on 11/20/08
  • Gravatar Warscreamer

    @Arghor
    If we would be so ridig, and said ‘defined by nature’ I would vote for druid flying form in combat, why not.. its instant..
    all other races have to spend some times on casting so this can be interrupted, but our shifting is instant!
    yay!

    …. there is nothing like ‘by nature’ in WoW.
    simple.. rogue and feral cats are similar, ‘by nature’ and if Blizzard spot that some skill can make one class better than other they just must change/add something.

    10:25 am on 11/20/08
  • Gravatar Lheaf

    Totally with Arghor on this. Making every class the same really kills the class-love, I think. I used to love bear tanking. Now I’ve pretty much set aside leveling focus for my TBC epicced druid and shadowpriest, and am having more fun with my just-hit-70 shaman (perhaps the least touched class in this expansion thus far? Or at least behind the scenes foolery rather than in_your_face_class_shifting_changes).

    Thanks so much for posting this though! I love love love the images that go with your posts, and that get sent to my google reader with them! They make me giggle at work :)

    10:34 am on 11/20/08
  • Gravatar Currant

    Thanks for the comments, both funny and critical!

    I have to admit I’m of the camp that believes AoE damage capability isn’t really something Cat form needs. That said, if it is desired that Ferals do AoE dps (rather than tanking, and no matter how sporadic the ability) the ability really should be Cat specific.

    11:20 am on 11/20/08
  • Gravatar Muriel

    Some kind of “claw rage” ala the Zuljin fight would be a lot of fun. Blizz could make it require a catnip reagent and call it “Scratching Post” or “Not on the Drapes!”

    12:18 pm on 11/20/08
  • Gravatar Talonscorch

    I would have to agree that a AOE ability is not rly needed for Cats as they are a single target design of DPS just like rogues. If I want to aoe I hop out and cast hurricane or go bear on them. The fact that majority of rogues feel they “HAVE TO” be on top of some stupid damage meter all the time just is agitating. I rather get the job done right then worry about some damage meter determining if I’m the best any day.

    12:33 pm on 11/20/08
  • Gravatar Spectrum

    I primarily play a paladin these says. My tree will my next to level, but that won’t be for a while.

    Playing a paladin I’ve been very impressed by the two spell-power conversion talents. One gives protection paladins spell power based on their stamina(http://www.wowhead.com/?spell=53592), and the other gives retribution paladins spell power based on their attack power(http://www.wowhead.com/?spell=53503). These talents make both classes able to use their spell-power-based skills, which ends up mostly being heals, without having to wear SP gear. This way they can still toss out a few heals when needed instead of effectively taking them off their bars.

    I think ferals could use something similar. If Nurturing Instinct were changed to increase your spell power based on attack power then hurricane would become a reasonable form of AE for ferals. You wouldn’t have the best AE by far, but if you wanted that you could have specced balance.

    1:05 pm on 11/20/08
  • Gravatar Tone

    If AoE DPS is something that they feel Rogues and Ferals should have, I agree that it’d be better to have it as a Cat Form ability (instead of Bear Swipe). Maybe it’s not a problem these days with how strong a Tank’s threat generation is, but the idea of a Bear in DPS gear, Swiping away at everything, seems pretty risky. It would be like a Ret Paladin turning on Righteous Fury to cast Consecration.

    @Shasmo: I love the “Bath Time” idea :-) … and if they ever decided to also give Cats a Vanish, they could call it “Knock at the Door!” :-o

    1:21 pm on 11/20/08
  • Gravatar Warscreamer

    @Talonscorch
    well.. I can say ‘ferals dont need AoE’.
    The question is not if they do, but
    Don’t we buff rogues by giving them AoE?
    If you are in small guild, on calm and friendly server where you can raid only with friends, you have a chance to raid anytime you want, you dont have to fight for quest mobs.. thats ok.

    but there is many, many places, where feral druids must compete with rogues for the one and only (or maybe two) raid slot.
    and if rogues will beat ferals in DPS more and more, ferals will start to lose this fight.

    Once again.
    I’m not telling that feral AoE is against or not ‘feral nature’, I’m talking about balance.

    Lets give priests more HoTs, more Instant Healing, increase mana regen by 100% and hmmm.. well..thats enough.
    Some druids will said ‘well.. I just like to be a druid so Ill keep playin’
    but after two weeks of ‘-sorry mon, but we already have three priests on healing, maybe next month’ they will start to whine.

    1:42 pm on 11/20/08
  • Gravatar Yggdrasil

    The problem for Rogues is that they lack the tangible sorts of utility we expect from other classes. They bring no buffs, their debuffs do not boost group/raid damage (or if they do, they can’t be used due to issues for the tank if its a Warrior), no heals, and can only tank in the most liberal sense of the term, regardless of spec they choose.

    So, yes, Rogues are obsessed with damage. Its the only *tangible* thing they bring to a group/raid. No one brings a Rogue for anything else, unless there is a specific scenario that needs a door unlocked or something (a la Shattered Halls). In a single target DPS race, particularly 1 that is not designed to be favorable to casters, Rogues usually DO rule the roost, all things being equal, but the margin isn’t so wide as to be obscene. On the other hand, in an AoE scenario, Rogues fall far behind. If other clases do 90% of the damage a Rogue does in single target scenarios, and do twice the damage Rogues do in AoE scenarios, why bring a Rogue? If other classes have more reliable CC, that can be reapplied in combat, can bring buffs, and will take less damage in the course of doing their job by virtue of just being further away from the enemy, why bring a Rogue?

    Now, of course, I’ll say that I LOVE having a *good* Rogue in my group. They are bar none awesome when it comes to handling “oh crap” situations. I can’t count the number of times a tank goes down at the with a boss at <10% hp, and a Rogue popped Evasion and tanked it out, or the number of times a tank’s screw up didn’t mean a dead healer, because a Rogue was there to pick up the slack. Even then, you have to wonder if Rogues will be supplanted in this role by Death Knights, whose damage output is on par (or better), *and* they have some powerful AoE abilities, *and* they can tank, *and* they bring powerful buffs/debuffs that boost raid/group wide DPS, and even a unique talented effect that reduces incoming damage.

    I don’t play a Rogue, but Rogues definitely need a buff to their AoE. If DPS kitties are meant to be taken seriously as anything other than poorly specced offtanks, and that is supposedly the case, and probably need an AoE ability that is relevant to their gear and talents. Hurricane is “better than nothing” but in Feral/Rogue gear and without talents, not by a lot.

    4:46 pm on 11/20/08
  • Gravatar Wise Fox

    Am I blind, as I can’t see any specific reference to it being cat form that they are thinking about giving the AOE to, could it not be bear form? I thought I recalled something about bear tanks getting aoe to compare with paladins?

    Or is it just the conversation was in reference to rogues, so when they talk about feral they mean our rogue form being cat?

    Wise Foxs last blog post..Vices

    8:55 pm on 11/20/08
  • Gravatar Warscreamer

    ok.
    I have to admit that I was wrong.

    new AOE must be feral bear talent.
    I spent some time yesterday in heroic Oculus.
    Before WotLK small dragons like whelps were rather easy and painless.
    Here if you have a healer without instant heals one whelp can destroy everything, and because I have only growl and challenging roar I was unable to taunt lose whelps.
    It was just Demo Roar, swipe loop for a minute.

    A aoe, A aoe, My kingdom for AOE!

    5:13 am on 11/24/08
  • Gravatar gus

    just read on mmo champion that the new aoe for cats will be swipe for kitties :)

    3:15 pm on 11/24/08

Trackbacks

Comments RSS Feed   TrackBack URL

Leave a comment

 

Recent Comments

Living Seed, Replenish, and Gift of the Earthmother (15)

Phaelia
@Perrin: Thank you for the clarification. Your description of the interaction between the two is very succinct and easy to understand so I’ve adopted your wording above. I hope that’s okay. :-) @Kiryn: Have you considered the fact that Rejuvenation + Swiftmend is a 1.5 second cast while Regrowth is only 2? I know that you aren’t having trouble with mana, but a Regrowth will hit harder and provide more potential benefits (crit = Nature’s Grace and possibly Living...

Kloro
Even though Replenish gives utility to Rejuvenation, my job is healing and I won’t put talent points in something that doesn’t explicitly contribute to healing. The only time I use Rejuvenation in a raid setting is when I need to Swiftmend someone who doesn’t already have a HoT on them. It simply is too slow and weak to be of use before another healer tops up the player.

Werebeef
I don’t think viewing living seed as a % of total healing is really the best way to look at it. It’s great for helping a player that is at very low health get back up to very high health and do so quickly. You don’t look at nature’s swiftness as a percentage of overall healing. I don’t think it makes that much sense here either. It’s also a talent that is better when the content is hard, when you have less overhealing. There’s also something...

Kalfurion
Hi Phae, long time no talk. I want to point out that I’m 0/0/71 and I love it. I don’t really find the talents in the balance tree to be that useful for my needs. I’m in a raiding guild as I’m sure you know and the three talents you spoke about suit my needs so well. My rogues, DK’s and our feral druid love me when I keep a rejuv on them for replenish. I’ve joined pugs and people look at my spec and make silly jokes and I don’t know why,...

Kiryn
I really like Replenish, personally. I find myself with far more mana regen than I need in most boss fights, so mana conservation isn’t much of an issue for me. I don’t even know why I carry mana potions if I never use them, and I’m far more likely to be innervating the priests than myself. I often treat rejuv-swiftmend as a near-instant 8k heal on a 15 second cooldown. It isn’t cheap, but it can bring someone back from the brink of death in a little over a second...
Guest Post: Leveraging Shadowmeld (23)

Penguinator
Our guild tried instructor Razuvious in H naxx and we had to try many different strategies, wiping a bunch or times because we had only 1 priest. Most of the time, i was assigned to raid healing and could heal in a corner above the arena. Whenever our tank died and he started one-shotting our raid (90k on a clothie, 30k on a tank) i shadowmelded and could start rezzing people. This was very useful, especially when the pallies ran out of reagents to DI.

Riverwish
As far as i’m aware they changed it so that when you meld in a raid instance you don’t leave combat so you can’t drink/eat or reset pot cooldowns in a raid bossfight, this is why you have to be quite lucky at escaping combat in a raid situation. I did manage to escape for Patchwerk numerous times but other bosses are trickier, I think it depends really on who your fighting and what room you’re in :) All these things can be done in 5 mans though. Riverwishs...

Vreenash
Thanks for posting this up Phae :) Keep the ideas flowing guys. It’s good to hear the different ideas and situations you’ve all been using shadowmeld in. Here’s another one for you: While leveling my way to 78 (still with the ground mount in northrend), there were quests that required killing a normal mob boss. They were usually in the centre of a town, camp or cave. Instead of killing all the mobs on the way to boss, just mount up and run directly to him....

Bearess
One note about SM that should be brought up. Yes it will bring you out of the fight in a lot of cases, but some bosses can still find you. AOE attacks will bring you out of a SM. So watch that. I learned that the hard way when Instructor Razuvious broke loose, and I skittered off a corner and SM. His next “victim” was too close to me when he let out his “Distrupting Shout” and I became next on his list. Figured I’d drop a line since it is a weakness to SM...

Arcaedus
Great info! I’ve often used SM to get out of combat when soloing but have put it to limited use in the instance/raid environment. @Riverwish: I’m not sure that you have to be the last player alive/targetable. I’ve had both successful and unsuccessful attempts with SM hiding on a wipe. My main example is on Patchwork. When multiple tanks go down and its a sure wipe, you are able to run behind one of the pillars and meld. As long as no one drags Patchy to you he should...
© 2008 Resto4Life. Some Rights Reserved. Original theme by Dezinerfolio. Respecced by Phaelia.